Monday, January 11, 2010

The Psychology of Sin

We live in times where psychology is primarily curative. One who feels the bite of trauma or the confusion of mental illness is prompted to explore the human condition, to clarify and remedy his fault. As such, a stigma has developed, one who frequents a shrink is ‘different’, is less complete or less healthy than his peers.

Depression and boredom ravage contemporary western homes. Consumerist society harnesses this desperation and feeds it, filling that void with more emptiness; be it the endless visual stimulation of TV, the pseudo-challenges of graphic computer games or the meaningless noise that fills our iPods. Essentially it boils down to avoidance. We stifle ourselves with a ruckus above which the call for meaning can never be heard. But we are largely unsuccessful; the more we avoid ourselves, ignoring that gaping vacuum, the louder its cry becomes and the more we are racked by fear.

We can’t turn for help because that’s weakness. Freud writes that the first indication that one is sick, is that he questions the meaning of his life. Our insecurities resonate with this notion and it sounds right. So we ignore ourselves and just keep paddling downstream until it kills us.

What society needs is a psychology which is preventative, not curative. An outlook on life that affirms it, giving it optimism and hope. Every individual is bound to face the harshness of life. Viktor Frankl, the father of the psychological school of Logotherapy, inspired by his experiences in the holocaust, refers to the tragic triad experience by humankind: suffering, guilt and death. These are elements of existence which challenge even the most courageous of humanity. How are we to face them? How can they possibly contribute to healthy living? How should we react to the mistakes of our past?

Chassidic thought is unique in that in explaining G-d, it explains humanity. The image of man is one with that of his creator. And it is in this sense that man cannot be religious if he is not healthy. He cannot love G-d if his heart is lost to licentiousness. He cannot fathom G-d if his brain is dulled by the glow of a plasma screen. Amongst its most fundamental premises is that in directing oneself to G-d one must first focus on his own self. In the words of the early sages; ‘a healthy soul needs a healthy body’. A man of G-d is exactly that: a man, of G-d.

Yeridah Le’tzorech Aliyah. Ascent demands descent.

Life sees us both stumble and triumph. Mistakes of the past are commonly glossed over, ignored and sent deep into the recesses of our subconscious. Psychotherapy has revealed the great dangers of such repressed experiences; how the minutiae of our deeds are controlled by the proper nurture we did or did not receive. Wrongs committed upon innocent children today, form the broken adults of tomorrow.

Sin is suffering. It’s when we let that which is black dominate our lives, when we lose the moral strength to do battle and instead give in to the torrents of pressure from both within and without. But sin isn’t so bad. As a matter of fact, sin can give us the impetus to rise more powerfully and with more conviction than ever before. How many people do we know who have formed intensely positive lives because of a single negative act of disastrous outcome? I have seen people born to abusive relationships, who have dedicated themselves to finding peace between husband and wife. I have watched those who witnessed the lethal harm of cigarettes do everything in their power to stop their loved ones smoking. The philosopher Nietzsche wrote that whatever does not kill you, makes you stronger. Life’s errors can form its greatest triumphs.

The tragic triad creates a tension in our lives. Suffering negates complacency. Guilt demands remorse and rectification. Death makes us acutely aware of life’s transience and promotes activity, productivity and wards off procrastination. Each negative element of life is seen through the lens of Chassidic thought as the ultimate spur to morally healthy living. Every decline exists purely for the motivation which it provides our future.

Within the transformation of our past, Chassidic thought speaks of two modes; Teshuvah Me’yirah, ‘Repentance born of Fear’ and Teshuvah Me’ahavah, ‘Repentance born of Love’. The difference is not merely in the cause of the remorse, be it insecurity or strength, but more significantly in the way that each resolves the past.

A mistake in life may be feared; the damage seen as irreparable. As such, instinct demands that one regrets, gains forgiveness and strides boldly forwards. Such a man has ‘moved on’ and is not tethered by his past, but his past has given him nothing. It is a blot which he has managed to white out. Such a man does not wish to be reminded of his past; he wishes not to have to re-live the experience which caused such hardship. This attitude is known as splitting, reflected in the Talmudic injunction not to pain converts by reminding them of their past.

Conversely, life’s errors may be approached with love, or strength. Errors may be welcomed as a sign of ones humanity. We aren’t robots and we do err. We have no right to, but we do. We just do. A healthy self-image will refuse to split ones current ‘self’ from the ‘self’ of ones past. One cannot simply throw away an experience into the abyss of despair and regret. To the contrary, one gains inspiration from weakness. It is used to propel one towards good, to harness the passion of crime and convert it to kindness.

In Judaism, we don’t live in the past, but we do live with the past. We don’t try to forget the fact that we were once slaves in Egypt. Daily, we remind ourselves of the bleakness of our history. But it does not get us down because our memory is not one of self-pity. We do not wallow. Rather our memory has the dual focus of remembering G-d’s care for us at the time of our vulnerability and ensuring that we never perpetuate prejudice upon ‘the strangers in our own midst.’ The horrors we experienced ensure that we never perpetuate those self-same deeds on others. George Santayana famously wrote, ‘a nation that cannot remember its past is condemned to repeat it.’ This notion accurately reflects the individual as well. Past and present must synthesise to create the tension necessary for healthy living. Our lives are stories, of which every chapter is meaningful, the pitfalls perhaps even more so than the moments of grandeur.

Judaism demands that we run against the grain. Society’s natural instinct is to flee from the tragic triad to the safe haven of dope and wealth. Chassidic thought demands that it be confronted. A prisoner cannot free himself, he needs a warden to do so. Humanity cannot free itself from unrest that plagues it. The more it attempts to fill the void, the deeper it becomes. Take the advice of the warden; embrace misfortune, don’t shy from guilt. Let it permeate your being and let the tension it exudes form the impetus to rise above and to grow. Yeridah le’tzorech Aliyah.